The 100 million club: the bigger picture of mobile software
- 12 comments
- view license
[Research Director Andreas Constantinou, discusses the latest update to VisionMobile's 100 million club, and the bigger picture that emerges from our research, including de facto standards and software that's truly mass-market]
We ‘ve just released the updated version of our 100 million club: the watchlist of software companies whose products have been embedded on more than 100 million mobile handsets.
[update: the latest edition of the 100 million club is here]
In this H1 2008 update we ‘ve identified 25 software products from 23 companies which have shipped on more than 100 million handsets cumulatively as of June 2008. The watch list provides the basis for three key observations (especially in comparison to our 2007 update):
- Firstly the 100 million club is a testament to the commercial and technological complexities inherent in the mobile industry; there are over 6 billion handsets having been shipped up to June 2008 and around 1.2 billion handsets estimated to be shipped in 2008. Yet our research shows that only 4 software products have reached the 1 billion deployment mark, 9 products have exceeded the 500 million mark and 25 products in total have shipped in more than 100 million handsets. Considering that there are 250-300 companies that license embedded software products – not to mention the circa 30,000 mobile software developers – this is clearly a tough market in which to achieve scale. Indeed, the revenues and developer mindshare are migrating from the pre-load to the post-sales phase of the handset lifecycle, as we ‘ve covered in an earlier article (mobile software is dead.. long live mobile software).
(click for the download page)
- Secondly, the results of the research point to the de facto standards that are emerging with regards to software components. Adobe’s Flash Lite has been embedded on 723 million handsets as of June 2008. Adjusting for seasonal variations, Flash Lite is being deployed on over 500 million handsets per year in 2008 – phenomenal numbers and close to challenging the penetration of Java ME implementations which are generally estimated to around 80% of the global sales base. On the other hand, browser shipments are slowing down (see earlier article on Bye Bye Browser). The Openwave (now Purple Labs) browser was shipped on 180 million devices in H1 2008 and Opera Mobile shipped on just under 20M handsets in that same period. The de facto standards here are under the radar for the time being; WebKit (which should make it into the 100 million club in H2 2008 thanks to Nokia’s S60 and S40 pre-installs) and Opera Mini which saw over 95 million downloads in total as of August 2008. Nuance is also a company to watch, given that it tops our 100 million club with a clear margin to the second runner, and is expanding across multiple forms of text input technologies.
- Thirdly, the watch list points to some surprising observations on mass-market software. The industry talks too much about smartphone software – Symbian, S60, Windows Mobile and Android – yet these are overshadowed by the volume deployments of feature phone operating systems. Mentor Graphics’ Nucleus and ENEA’s OSE have been deployed on well over 1 billion handsets, in many cases as the single OS powering both the applications and the modem stack. Nokia’s S40 has been embedded on an estimated 730 million handsets, while Qualcomm’s BREW has been shipped on an estimated 469 million handsets in total. Both S40 and BREW expose a large part of the device capabilities to software developers and force into question the term ‘open OS’ which is typically associated with Symbian and Windows Mobile.
All in all, the 100 million club lists 25 products which have shipped on more that 100 million handsets as of June 2008, grouped into five product categories:
- Application environments: Adobe Flash Lite, Aplix Jblend and Esmertec Jbed.
- Browsers: ACCESS Netfront, Opera Mobile, Picsel File Viewer and the Purple Labs (ex Openwave) browser.
- Middleware: Beatnik MobileBAE, BitFlash Mobile SVG, Ikivo SVG Player, Nuance VSuite, NXP Software’s LifeVibes MxMedia, PacketVideo CORE, Red Bend vCurrent, Scalado CAPS and TAT Kastor.
- Operating systems: ENEA OSE, Mentor Graphics Nucleus, Nokia S60, Nokia S40, Open Kernel Labs OKL4, Qualcomm BREW and Symbian OS.
- Input engines: Nuance T9 and Zi eZiText.
For a detailed discussion of the common traits of the companies listed in the 100 million club see our 2007 update of the watch list. Note that the 100 million club is based on an original article by Morten Grauballe.
We have excluded ARM, InnoPath and Sun from the watch list as they were unable to disclose exact shipment numbers for their products, and Teleca’s Obigo browser which has been discontinued since May 2007.
Warm congratulations to the vendors who have succeeded in crossing the 100 million handset mark!
- Andreas
SVG widespread among browsers, middleware and operating systems to the least. And i wouldn’t be surprised to see it in “Application environments” as well.
Hi Stelt,
True – Ikivo and Bitflash put together account for nearly 600 shipped handsets with SVG players embedded, so fairly substantial penetration, roughly double that of all smartphone operating systems put together.
I wouldn’t see it in application environments though – the SVG standard isn’t designed to expose device APIs (beyond vector graphics) or deal with application lifecycle management like application environments do.
- Andreas
I guess you mean 600 million
But keep counting as at least ACCESS Netfront and Opera Mobile also have SVG support.
Anybody else know of SVG support in others listed?
Hi Andreas,
the SVG standard on its own does not expose device APIs, but implementations of it ship with APIs. Typical examples would JSR-226 implementations that expose both SVG and the other Java APIs, or the cases in which SVG is used for the phone’s UI and in which Javascript has access to the device APIs. I understand where you’re coming from though, this information is hardly well-known.
Also you would have to count Access and Opera at the least, plus WebKit which ships with SVG in some devices (notably the iPhone, though that’s not such a huge volume). A number of others (e.g. RIM) also have some SVG support of their own, though not necessarily the latest.
All in all, you sure are right that it’s a confusing picture
Hi Corporation’s – http://www.hicorp.co.jp/english/ – mascot capsule 3d engine is included on pretty much every SonyEricsson handset for the last 5 years, and on most Japanese handsets. So, I would think they qualify for the 100 million club.
Robin – interesting to hear about the bigger picture of SVG deployments. Thanks for sharing.
cb – thanks for bringing this to our attention. We ‘ll contact HI Corp for the next edition of the 100 million club.
Andreas
Great post!
Strategy Analytics reported that Flash Lite has a current installed base of 689m devices. That is devices that aren’t just using flash for their UI currently in the market.
We have also just announced the Flash Lite Distributable Player beta, and with this product you can now auto-update your Flash player on demand. Right now we are live in US/Italy/Spain and we’ll expand this in short order.
http://www.adobe.com/go/distribute
Its a very exciting time for us and of course much will change later in 2009 when we release Flash 10 and AIR to our partners.
Mark Doherty
Adobe – Mobile and Devices
Hi Mark,
We benchmark devices shipped rather than the installed base and it’s interesting that Strategy Analytics forecast 922m devices shipped by end 2008, which would seem a pessimistic estimate based on the end-07 (450M) and end-1H08 (723M) shipments of Flash Lite given by Adobe.
In any case, Flash Lite is becoming a de facto standard, second only to Java ME’s penetration. What is very interesting is that Adobe now allows app developers to package an auto installer for FL with their apps for Symbian and WinMo environments – previously this was only possible on BREW.
The impact will be small since S60 3rd Edition already includes FL and WinMo is small volumes – but the distribution model is very promising if extended to other app environments or OEMs.
Andreas
http://www.funambol.com/solutions/capabilities.php says “Funambol is the leading provider of open source MobileWe for two billion handsets.”
Is the Funambol 2B handsets claim incorrect? If not then why is Funambol not on your list?
Hi Peter,
Funambol is NOT pre-installed on 2B handsets. They are probably claiming compatibility of MobileWe with two billion handsets in the installed base.
Andreas
Hi Andreas,
i didn’t quite catch note 3 about obigo browser, what does the “discontinued” mean?
Hi Shane,
Teleca discontinued support for the Obigo browser around April 2007. They are still shipping the browser for legacy OEM contracts, but the browser is no longer developed or supported by Teleca.
Andreas

visionmobile 2005-2010


