Distilling market noise into market sense

VisionMobile is the leading research company in the app economy. Our Developer Economics research program tracks developer experiences across platforms, revenues, apps, tools, APIs, segments and regions, via the largest, most global developer surveys.

Monetising apps: Lessons from the music industry

[VisionMobile analyst Stijn Schuermans muses about the similarities between the app economy and other businesses like FMCGs and music. What can app makers learn from other industries and how can these lessons help developers monetising apps?]

In a recent post on our newly launched Developer Economics portal with facts and insights for app developers – build.developereconomics.com – colleague Mark Wilcox likened the app economy to a retail business:
In the early days of relatively empty app stores, simply launching a good product was often sufficient to get noticed and soar up the store charts. However, as with any fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) business, the value within apps has shifted from the contents (the functionality) to the packaging (the user experience) and marketing.

I agree: packaging is crucial and the fight for shelf space is fierce, just like in retail. In the app business, this is called “app store optimization” (ASO).

Here’s an interesting thought: with which other industries can the app business be compared, and which lessons can we apply from those other industries to make developers more successful?

One industry that strikes me as pretty similar is the music industry. It too is experiencing a shift in competition: the internet has made it much easier for musicians to reach an audience. At the same time, this has undermined the traditional album-sales business model, making it much harder for musicians to make a living from their trade. Sounds familiar?

Direct sales of either apps or albums is no longer a sustainable business model, or at least it can’t be relied on anymore to make a living. There’s just too much competition (700.000 apps in the app store; everyone with an instrument and some YouTube skills), including from free apps and music. Some lucky ones are still making millions, but most who try hardly make any money at all. In our Developer Economics 2012 survey, we found that as much as half of the app developers live below the app poverty line, i.e. they don’t make enough money to sustain themselves. Apps and music sales are hit-driven businesses.

In the music industry, people are tackling this issue by moving to indirect sales methods: the revenue focus shifts from selling CDs to selling performances, special edition releases (direct to fan) and merchandise. The tracks themselves are often given away for free on a website or through an online music service to drive interest and discovery. Marketing guru Seth Godin has a nice way of explaining how this works: first, you create a tribe, i.e. a group of raving fans, he says. Then, you will have their permission to sell them souvenirs, for which they will happily pay a good price.

The merchandise model has made its way already into the app economy. The most obvious and well know example is Rovio, the mobile-first gaming company that already derives 30% of its revenue from physical goods related to its Angry Birds hit and aims to reach 50% in a few years time. However, this is not very helpful to other app developers: Rovio is not successful because it sells merchandise. Instead, Angry Birds merchandise sells because the game was a hit in the first place. This said, all apps related to non-digital brands basically use the same model implicitly: they use apps to drive physical-goods sales. Most of those apps will be free. The money comes from the goods being retailed.

I find this to be an immensely encouraging message for developers: the real app economy is a whole lot bigger than the numbers reported from paid apps, in-app purchases and advertising! Opportunity is abundant.

What do you think? Which other lessons can app developers take from the music industry and others?

– Stijn (@stijnschuermans)

  • There are other parallels to the music industry. The advent of digital music destablized what was a tightly vertically integrated industry. The apps space was the same way prior to the launch of iTunes. In the music space iTunes became the primary store for distribution but not the ONLY store. There we hundreds of distribution outlets for music from well-known outlets like Napster & Rhapsody to non-branded outlets like mobile carriers and hundreds of smaller & international distribution points. With the launch of Android we see the same thing – lots of outlets popping up to distribute apps. In the music space companies like Tunecore and ReVerbNation made it easier for independents artists to reach these stores. In the app space we're seeing companies like CodeNgo look to fill a similar role. The parallels won't end there as the creators of both music and apps do so for both money and passion so even if riches aren't promised we'll still see developers innovating on what came before them.

    • Stijn Schuermans

      Excellent point about the pain (and cost!) of distribution! Our Developer Economics surveys consistently show that reach is the primary goal for most app developers (as fame is for musicians?), and that money comes second. It would be very interesting for app developers to look to musicians for tips on how to get in front of more eyeballs with less effort.

  • No doubt new and innovative technology is at the forefront of the music industry. This is prime example of it first hand.


Distilling market noise into market sense

What gets desktop developers out of bed in the morning?

desktop developer segmentation

Despite all the hype around the death of the PC and the enormous amount of media attention focused on mobile,…

Continue reading ...

A proven model for targeting IoT developers


  What if you could identify a handful of developer personas, or segments, each with a very distinct set of…

Continue reading ...

1000 skills: Amazon Alexa as a metaphor for the IoT developer community


Alexa is a centerpiece of Amazon’s Smart Home push, and quickly growing to become one of the most promising attempts…

Continue reading ...


Research on the app economy and developer ecosystems

Developer Segmentation 2014


The Developer Segmentation Q3 2014 report is the most sophisticated study of developer segments to date. The report delivers a…

Continue reading ...

App Profits and Costs


This research report examines the critical success factors for a profitable app, and how business and technology choices, such as…

Continue reading ...

Developer Segmentation 2013

Developer Segmentation 2013

The Developer Segmentation 2013 report delivers a needs-based segmentation model that actually works, with extensive profiling of the eight principle…

Continue reading ...